Cinnamon Honey Butter Recipe

Take your toast, biscuits, and dinner rolls to the next level with our cinnamon honey butter recipe – just like you’d find at that steak house with the crazy good rolls! This creamy whipped butter is combined with sweet honey and warm cinnamon that will elevate whatever you spread it on!

Hello, my name is Karly and it’s been approximately 3 minutes since I last spread some cinnamon honey butter over a piece of toast and devoured it all in one bite.

I need an intervention, guys!

This cinnamon honey butter is everything that dreams are made of – creamy butter, sweet honey, warm cinnamon – and it all comes together in one bowl in minutes!

We’ve been finding excuses to make my dad’s famous homemade biscuits, our quick dinner rolls, and our Instant Pot sweet potatoes every chance we get because each one of those is just perfect topped with this recipe for cinnamon honey butter!

Table of Contents

Ingredient Notes:

This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon associate and member of other qualifying programs, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Ingredients for cinnamon honey butter on counter.

Butter – This cinnamon honey butter recipe starts with a whole stick of salted butter. Be sure to let the butter sit out for a bit to soften up.

Honey – Whenever possible I try to use local honey if I can find it but any kind you prefer will work. I’ve linked to my favorite store bought honey.

Powdered Sugar – This will help thicken up the mixture a bit and of course and add more sweet flavor to the honey butter with cinnamon.

Cinnamon & Salt – There is just something magical about the combination of cinnamon and sugar! We’re also using a pinch of salt to help balance out all that sweetness from the honey and sugar.

What Readers are Saying!

“This recipe is easy and delicious. Had to try it right away on toast, soooo good!” – Lori

How to Make Honey Butter with Cinnamon:

It sounds easy enough to just add a bit of honey with some butter and I’m sure that would be lovely, but if we want the right flavor and consistency, we need to add a little extra goodness. Ready for this?

Collage showing how to make cinnamon honey butter.

Butter: You’ll take a stick of room temperature butter and add in a hefty drizzle of honey. Add in some powdered sugar and a little cinnamon. A little pinch of salt helps bring out the flavors.

Combine: Use a mixer to beat the cinnamon honey butter mixture all together until it’s thick, creamy, and well combined.

You’re done! Spread your butter into a jar to store in the fridge or serve it up right away. It’s tastiest when it’s room temp, so be sure to pull it from the fridge about an hour before you plan to serve it for the best taste and texture.

My Favorite Hand Mixer!

It’s so easy to whip up dessert with this cute hand mixer. It doesn’t take up much space and is a must for any kitchen!

Get on amazon

Storage:

Store your cinnamon honey butter in a sealed jar or bowl in the refrigerator for 2-3 months, depending on how fresh your butter is.

We love these jars with a locking lid. So convenient and cute!

What To Serve With Honey Butter:

Oh my, the list is endless! I’ve got some great recipes that I think would go well with this butter:

FAQ’S:

Does honey butter need to be refrigerated?

We store our cinnamon honey butter in the refrigerator if we’ll be keeping it longer than a day. It does taste best at room temperature, so we remove from the fridge about an hour before serving or we zap it in the microwave for 10-15 seconds.

How long will honey butter last?

This cinnamon honey butter recipe should last in the fridge for as long as your butter is good. I’d recommend checking the expiration date of your butter and use the freshest you can find.

MORE RECIPES WITH HONEY!

Close up of cinnamon honey butter in jar.

Recipe